← Back to Directory
CSI: NY
TV Series

CSI: NY

2004Action, Crime, Drama • 9 Seasons

Woke Score
1.8
out of 10

Series Overview

CBS's successful CSI franchise gets transplanted to the Big Apple. Cases involving sewer rats as witnesses, a victim whose head was slammed in a pizzeria oven, and murders of commodities traders, and--of course--a Red Sox fan. CSI: NY is a bleaker, grimmer version of its Las Vegas and Miami cousins. The team is made up of a pleasantly New Yawk but indistinct cast of characters. The teams leader Detective Mac Taylor (Gary Sinise), is a former Marine from Chicago. Mac is a veteran of the NYPD who lost his wife on 9/11, and as such must work to rebuild his personal life while supervising his team. He is organized, efficient, dedicated, and very proper in his management style. His second in command for the first 6 seasons is Detective Stella Bonasera (Melina Kanakaredes), Stella is half-Greek, half-Italian, and entirely New York City. She helped Mac through the impact of his wife's death and has been by his side ever since. She is a savvy investigator, yet she often speaks before she thinks. Stella leaves New York to head a crime lab in New Orleans and is replaced by Detective Jo Danville (Sela Ward). Jo is a former FBI criminalist and an experienced psychological profiler. She and Mac quickly form a strong friendship and an even stronger working rapport. Jo is still haunted by her ousting from the FBI after blowing the whistle on improper lab procedure, so she works to regain her professional reputation. Joining them is younger CSIs Danny Messer (Carmine Giovinazzo), Aiden Burn (Vanessa Ferlito, who has since left the show), Aiden's replacement Lindsay Monroe (Anna Belknap) and medical examiner turned CSI Sheldon Hawkes (Hill Harper). Rounding out the cast is the teams legal muscle Homicide Detective Don Flack (Eddie Cahill), Medical Examiner Sid Hammerback, M.D. (Robert Joy) and lab tech Adam Ross (A. J. Buckley).

Weekly Alert

Get the Weekly Woke Watchlist

New and trending movies scored for woke bias, preachy messaging, and forced political themes — before you waste your evening.

No spam. One useful email per week.

Season-by-Season Breakdown

Season 1

1.2/10

No overview available.

View Full Season Analysis

Season 2

2/10

No overview available.

View Full Season Analysis

Season 3

2/10

No overview available.

View Full Season Analysis

Season 4

1.6/10

No overview available.

View Full Season Analysis

Season 5

1.6/10

No overview available.

View Full Season Analysis

Season 6

2/10

No overview available.

View Full Season Analysis

Season 7

1.6/10

No overview available.

View Full Season Analysis

Season 8

2/10

No overview available.

View Full Season Analysis

Season 9

2/10

No overview available.

View Full Season Analysis

Overall Series Review

CSI: NY stands as a definitive example of the mid-2000s procedural drama, centered on the pursuit of objective truth through rigorous forensic science. Across its nine seasons, the series presents a world where professional merit, technical expertise, and individual integrity serve as the primary benchmarks for success. Under the stoic leadership of Mac Taylor, a character defined by his Marine background and deep sense of patriotic duty, the team functions as a cohesive unit dedicated to upholding law and order in a gritty, high-stakes urban environment. The narrative consistently prioritizes the importance of Western institutions, framing law enforcement as a vital shield against chaos. Rather than engaging in modern social agendas or identity-based narratives, the show focuses on the mechanics of criminal investigation and the psychological motives behind crimes. The diverse cast is integrated through shared purpose and mutual respect, with characters defined by their competence and actions rather than immutable traits. This grounded approach ensures that the pursuit of justice remains the central focus, unaffected by shifting trends in social commentary. Family and traditional domestic values are woven throughout the series, particularly through the evolving relationship between Danny Messer and Lindsay Monroe. These personal arcs reinforce the importance of the nuclear family, balancing the demands of high-pressure police work with the responsibilities of parenthood and marriage. By maintaining this steady, principled focus from start to finish, the series honors the resilience of New York City and the sacrifices of those who serve its citizens. Throughout its run, CSI: NY remains a steadfast procedural that upholds the value of scientific accuracy and the necessity of moral clarity in society.

Categorical Breakdown

Identity Politics1.9/10

Oikophobia1/10

Feminism2.2/10

LGBTQ+1.3/10

Anti-Theism1.9/10

Weekly Alert

Get the Weekly Woke Watchlist

New and trending movies scored for woke bias, preachy messaging, and forced political themes — before you waste your evening.

No spam. One useful email per week.