← Back to Doctor Who
Doctor Who Season 3
Season Analysis

Doctor Who

Season 3 Analysis

Season Woke Score
4
out of 10

Season Overview

The series stars David Tennant as the Doctor. In the Christmas special he is joined by Catherine Tate as Donna Noble. The series also introduces Freema Agyeman as the Doctor's new companion Martha Jones. John Barrowman also reprises his role as Captain Jack Harkness in the final three episodes which serve as the finale. The series is connected by a loose story arc consisting of the recurring phrase "Vote Saxon".

Season Review

Season 3 is characterized by strong female characters, the reintroduction of an openly pansexual character, and an arc that tackles complex issues of identity and the nature of humanity. The companion, Martha Jones, is a highly capable medical student and a Black woman whose race is acknowledged explicitly in one historical episode when she fears being taken as a slave, setting a precedent for addressing race in the narrative. Her strength is a recurring theme, but the primary conflict for her is unrequited love, not systemic oppression. The finale's main villain, The Master, takes over the UK government, leading to a critique of unchecked political power and the darker potential of humanity's future. The season features a notable presence of fluid sexuality through Captain Jack Harkness, presented as normalized in the future, and an episode that offers a nuanced exploration of faith and hope, suggesting a mixed ideological landscape rather than a complete embrace of any single 'woke' framework.

Categorical Breakdown

Identity Politics5/10

The main companion, Martha Jones, is a Black female medical student whose competence is constantly proven. The narrative includes a direct acknowledgment of her race's vulnerability in Elizabethan England, avoiding a purely 'colorblind' historical casting. In the story 'Human Nature/The Family of Blood,' Martha is forced to adopt the historically racialized role of a maid to the Doctor’s human persona, rather than his niece as in the source novel, which uses an intersectional lens to emphasize her social subordination. However, the season does not portray white males as universally evil; the Doctor is the hero, and the white male villain, the Master, is an individual psychopathic antagonist, not a representation of 'whiteness' or patriarchy.

Oikophobia3/10

The central villain, the Master, takes over the modern British government under the banner 'Vote Saxon' and subjects the entire country to his rule, which is a symbolic deconstruction of contemporary Western political institutions. The ultimate fate of humanity in the distant future is revealed to be a horrifying, self-inflicted atrocity (the Toclafane), serving as a dark commentary on humanity's potential for self-destruction. The season's primary theme, however, is the Doctor's profound, enduring love and defense of humanity and its potential, which prevents the narrative from completely vilifying Western civilization or 'home culture.'

Feminism5/10

Martha Jones is a highly intelligent, resourceful medical professional who actively saves the Doctor on multiple occasions and demonstrates genuine heroism, aligning with the 'Girl Boss' trope. She ultimately chooses to leave the Doctor to pursue a life where she is respected and to care for her family, establishing agency outside of the Doctor's shadow. The relationship dynamics do not entirely emasculate the Doctor, who remains the central powerful figure. A key episode explores the Doctor's human alter-ego dreaming of a 'normal' life that includes marriage and children, which counters any explicit anti-natalist messaging.

LGBTQ+6/10

Captain Jack Harkness is a significant recurring character and the Doctor's first openly pansexual companion in the revived series, a fact that is not merely background but a characteristic of his identity. His fluid sexuality is explicitly normalized as a common trait in the 51st century, supporting the view that 'sexuality is fluid.' This marks a deliberate inclusion and centering of an alternative sexuality. However, the narrative does not focus on 'gender ideology' or vilify the traditional nuclear family structure in any plot-driving way, keeping the score from reaching the highest levels.

Anti-Theism2/10

One major episode, 'Gridlock,' features a community of 'Cat Nuns' who maintain faith and hope in a desperate situation, offering a spiritual narrative that is positive and centered on transcendence. The Doctor’s confrontation with the villain is described in terms of 'righteous rage and Old Testament fury,' which uses religious language to frame the concept of objective moral justice. The season does not frame traditional religion, specifically Christianity, as a root of evil, and it maintains a firm, objective moral law where the Master's actions are unambiguously evil.