← Back to The Mentalist
The Mentalist Season 2
Season Analysis

The Mentalist

Season 2 Analysis

Season Woke Score
2.2
out of 10

Season Overview

California Bureau of Investigation consultant Patrick Jane has a blatant lack of protocol but is self-assured and driven. The former "psychic" uses his talent for seeing the clues everyone else misses to solve the most baffling crimes. But there's more than crime: Lisbon and Cho reveal hints about their troubled pasts. Violence fells one CBI boss, and the new boss seems more interested in authority than teamwork. And as the Van Pelt-Rigsby relationship heats up, it threatens to cool down their careers.

Season Review

Season 2 of "The Mentalist" is a product of its time (2009-2010), focusing primarily on procedural crime-solving, the developing personal relationships within the team, and Patrick Jane's obsessive pursuit of the serial killer Red John. The narrative center is a traditional pursuit of justice and objective truth, using Jane's unique talent for observation and manipulation. The season introduces a new CBI boss following a violent event and explores the troubled pasts of Lisbon and Cho, rooting their character traits in personal trauma and redemption rather than systemic critique. The primary 'political' themes revolve around anti-establishment conduct (Jane's methods) versus law and order (Lisbon's adherence to rules), and a strong critique of cults and manipulative spirituality. The content is generally devoid of modern 'woke' ideology, lacking intersectional critiques, explicit anti-Western narratives, or forced sexual ideology.

Categorical Breakdown

Identity Politics2/10

Characters are overwhelmingly judged by their intellect, skills, and moral character, a universal meritocracy. Agent Cho's backstory involves successfully moving from a life of gang violence to becoming a highly competent CBI agent, which emphasizes personal agency and merit. Diversity in the main cast is present but is not used as a vehicle for political lecturing on privilege or systemic oppression.

Oikophobia2/10

The series focuses on individual crimes and the pursuit of justice by law enforcement, affirming the CBI as an institution, not condemning it as fundamentally corrupt. While some episodes feature corruption in the wealthy or political class, the narrative maintains a respect for the principle of law and order. Critiques of 'the system' are limited to Patrick Jane's personal disregard for protocol, not a deconstruction of Western heritage.

Feminism3/10

Teresa Lisbon holds the Senior Agent position and is the unit's competent boss, which is a position of female authority. However, she is a deeply flawed character with a difficult past who is often challenged and outmaneuvered by the hyper-competent male lead, Patrick Jane, precluding a 'Mary Sue' designation. Other male agents are also competent, suggesting a distinction of roles and skills rather than male emasculation. The romance between Agents Van Pelt and Rigsby focuses on career complications, not an anti-natalist or anti-family message.

LGBTQ+1/10

The narrative centers on traditional heterosexual dynamics, most prominently the developing romance between Van Pelt and Rigsby and Lisbon's past relationship with Agent Bosco. The season contains no detectable themes related to queer theory, centering of alternative sexualities, or the promotion of gender ideology. Sexuality is treated as a private matter that is incidental to the primary plot of crime-solving.

Anti-Theism3/10

Religion is featured explicitly in the recurring appearance of the manipulative cult, the 'Visualize Self-Realization Center,' which the show frames negatively as a source of corruption and evil. The central villain, Red John, and his acolytes advocate for moral relativism, which the hero, Patrick Jane, pointedly rejects, even if Jane is an atheist. Agent Lisbon is established as a woman of traditional Christian faith who maintains a strong moral compass and belief in objective truth, providing a counter-balance to the show's critique of fraudulent spirituality.