← Back to Directory
The Twilight Saga: New Moon
Movie

The Twilight Saga: New Moon

2009Adventure, Drama, Fantasy

Woke Score
3
out of 10

Plot

After Bella recovers from the vampire attack that almost claimed her life, she looks to celebrate her birthday with Edward and his family. However, a minor accident during the festivities results in Bella's blood being shed, a sight that proves too intense for the Cullens, who decide to leave the town of Forks, Washington for Bella and Edward's sake. Initially heartbroken, Bella finds a form of comfort in reckless living, as well as an even-closer friendship with Jacob Black. Danger in different forms awaits.

Overall Series Review

The Twilight Saga: New Moon is a dramatic romance centered on Bella Swan's profound depression and reckless behavior after her vampire boyfriend, Edward Cullen, leaves her. The plot focuses on her emotional reliance on men, specifically her friendship with Jacob Black, who is revealed to be a werewolf from the Quileute tribe. The story is driven by themes of tragic, forbidden love and the desire for eternal marriage, culminating in a desperate act to save Edward and a proposal. The film's overall message promotes complementarian gender roles, sexual abstinence, and commitment, which starkly contrasts with modern progressive narratives. However, the depiction of the Indigenous Quileute characters as primal, 'instinctual' werewolves in opposition to the 'civilized' European-descended vampires introduces racialized stereotypes and a problematic cultural dichotomy.

Categorical Breakdown

Identity Politics7/10

The narrative features a stark contrast between the two supernatural groups vying for the protagonist's love. The Indigenous Quileute characters, the werewolves, are portrayed as hot-headed, primal, and poor, tied to a purely natural, instinctual existence. This stands in opposition to the wealthy, rational, and highly civilized, predominantly white European-descended vampire coven, the Cullens, who practice self-control. This setup reduces the Native American Quileute people to the 'Noble Savage' trope and reinforces a hierarchy where 'whiteness' is associated with sophistication and rational control.

Oikophobia3/10

The film does not focus on the vilification or hatred of Western civilization. The primary setting is the small American town of Forks, and the heroine's home life, though strained, serves as an anchor. The story does romanticize the Quileute tribe and their natural world connection as an alternative to the European vampire world, but it does not frame American or Western culture as fundamentally corrupt or racist.

Feminism1/10

The main character, Bella Swan, is defined by her intense emotional dependence on her male love interest, Edward Cullen. Her entire existence is plunged into months of catatonic depression and self-destructive behavior after he leaves her. Bella's central ambition and source of fulfillment is not a career or personal achievement but transforming into a vampire to secure her eternal relationship and future with her husband-to-be. The narrative repeatedly shows her as vulnerable and in need of rescue by either Edward or Jacob, promoting a very traditional, patriarchal view of gender roles.

LGBTQ+1/10

The core plot is entirely focused on a traditional heterosexual love triangle between Bella, Edward, and Jacob. The ultimate trajectory of the protagonist is toward marriage and the nuclear family structure. The narrative presents sexuality as something private, dangerous, and needing extreme control and abstinence until marriage. No alternative sexualities are explicitly centered, and there is no discussion or political lecturing on gender theory.

Anti-Theism2/10

The story openly incorporates traditional Christian-like moral messaging, notably promoting sexual abstinence through the 'no sex until marriage' dynamic inherent in the vampire-human relationship. The Cullen family itself is presented as a moral unit of 'vegetarian' vampires who intentionally restrain their 'evil' nature and subscribe to a strong moral code centered on respect for human life and self-sacrifice. The plot's resolution revolves around Edward's ultimate willingness to sacrifice his immortality for Bella and his marriage proposal, emphasizing transcendent moral principles like sacrificial love and commitment.