← Back to Directory
Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales
Movie

Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales

2017Action, Adventure, Fantasy

Woke Score
3
out of 10

Plot

Captain Jack Sparrow (Johnny Depp) finds the winds of ill-fortune blowing even more strongly when deadly ghost pirates led by his old nemesis, the terrifying Captain Salazar (Javier Bardem), escape from the Devil's Triangle, determined to kill every pirate at sea...including him. Captain Jack's only hope of survival lies in seeking out the legendary Trident of Poseidon, a powerful artifact that bestows upon its possessor total control over the seas.

Overall Series Review

The fifth installment of the 'Pirates of the Caribbean' franchise offers a standard fantasy adventure that introduces a new heroine who drives the central quest. The film presents the character Carina Smyth as a woman of science who is persecuted and labeled a witch by the male authorities of the time, immediately establishing her intellectual superiority over the surrounding world. This dynamic contributes to a notable 'Girl Boss' feel, compounded by the writing that diminishes Captain Jack Sparrow to a more overtly bumbling and incompetent figure to elevate the new leads. The narrative's core remains a fantastical search for a magical artifact, the Trident of Poseidon, driven by the personal, familial goals of the main trio: Henry Turner, Carina Smyth, and the disgraced Captain Jack Sparrow. The movie ultimately restores the traditional nuclear family for the original heroes, Will Turner and Elizabeth Swann, and ends the new romantic pairing of Henry and Carina with a conventional resolution. Identity politics are not a primary focus of the plot, which concentrates on curses, revenge, and the swashbuckling tropes of the pirate genre. Explicit social lecturing is minimal, but the gender dynamics elevate one of the scores.

Categorical Breakdown

Identity Politics2/10

The plot focuses on personal vendettas, curses, and the pursuit of a mythological artifact rather than social hierarchy or race-based conflict. Characters succeed or fail based on their individual cunning, or lack thereof, such as Captain Jack Sparrow's incompetence or Carina's intellect. The villains are ghost pirates and representatives of the Spanish Crown, which is a standard pirate-genre conflict, not a lecture on intersectional privilege.

Oikophobia3/10

The film romanticizes the anti-authoritarian nature of piracy, which is a rejection of established Western institutions like the British and Spanish Navies. This is a continuation of the franchise's core premise rather than a targeted deconstruction of heritage. The primary antagonist, Captain Salazar, is a former Spanish commander whose goal was to eradicate piracy, placing the narrative's sympathy with the rebels/pirates.

Feminism7/10

The female lead, Carina Smyth, is a scientist who is accused of witchcraft due to the surrounding men's ignorance. She is consistently portrayed as the smartest person on screen, the only one who can decode the map to the Trident. Her intelligence is often highlighted by depicting Captain Jack Sparrow and the British Navy officers as bumbling, drunken, or hyper-superstitious fools. This utilizes the 'Girl Boss' trope at the expense of emasculating the long-established male lead's character. The final moments restore a focus on a romantic pairing and a father-daughter reunion, slightly mitigating a maximum score.

LGBTQ+1/10

The narrative centers on a quest motivated by the desire to reunite a male-female married couple and their son, which directly affirms the traditional nuclear family structure. The romantic pairing of the new leads, Henry Turner and Carina Smyth, is also male-female. There is no centering of alternative sexual identities or the introduction of gender ideology.

Anti-Theism3/10

The conflict features an institutionalized hostility towards science, as Carina is labeled a witch for possessing advanced astronomical knowledge. This element critiques religious superstition and ignorance. The film’s supernatural elements derive from Greek mythology (Poseidon, Trident) and sea goddess magic, not Christian allegory, which removes it from a direct anti-theistic position against traditional Western religion. Morality is transcendentally rooted in the rules of the sea's magical curses.