← Back to Directory
The Women in the Lakes
Movie

The Women in the Lakes

2024Unknown

Woke Score
4
out of 10

Plot

A 100-year-old resident of a Lake Biwa nursing home dies mysteriously. Did a respirator keeping him alive suddenly malfunction, or was he murdered? A young detective on the case meets a female caregiver. The investigation runs into a dead end, but the two fall into a passionate but forbidden relationship. Terrifying memories emerge from the vast, deep lake to ensnare the detectives on the case, the caregivers, and a reporter trying to uncover a hidden past.

Overall Series Review

The Women in the Lakes is a Japanese erotic murder mystery centered on the investigation of a 100-year-old man's death at a lakeside nursing home. The narrative follows a young male detective who becomes involved in a passionate but forbidden and immoral relationship with one of the female caregivers who is also a suspect. The mystery delves into a 'hidden past' and 'terrifying memories' from the past of the local community, suggesting dark secrets rooted in the locale. The film's overall tone is one of moral ambiguity and transgression, focusing on the dark psychology of its main characters rather than societal issues. Notably, the female lead is characterized by traditional feminine meekness, which contrasts sharply with the contemporary 'Girl Boss' trope, indicating a less 'woke' approach to gender dynamics.

Categorical Breakdown

Identity Politics2/10

The film is a Japanese production with a Japanese cast, and the primary conflicts are based on murder, criminal investigation, and personal moral transgression, not race or intersectional hierarchy. The story operates on a principle of character actions over immutable characteristics.

Oikophobia7/10

The plot's central mechanism involves a reporter trying to uncover a 'hidden past' and 'terrifying memories' emerging from the deep lake, which ensnares the detectives and caregivers. This focus on a dark, uncovered secret from the community's history suggests a narrative deconstruction and vilification of local institutions and heritage, framing the home culture as having a fundamentally corrupt moral past.

Feminism3/10

The main female protagonist is intentionally portrayed with delicate, meek, and frail characteristics, and her arc is tied to a man's twisted desire for control. This submissive characterization runs directly counter to the modern 'Girl Boss' or 'Mary Sue' trope, though another female character, a journalist, avoids this meekness. The focus is on traditional gender roles and sexual dynamics, even in a transgressive context.

LGBTQ+1/10

The core forbidden relationship is exclusively heterosexual, between a young male detective and a female caregiver/suspect. There is no evidence of alternative sexualities being centered, nor is there any presence of gender ideology or deconstruction of the nuclear family.

Anti-Theism6/10

The film is an 'erotic murder mystery' centered on a 'passionate but immoral relationship' and the 'darker side of humanity,' suggesting human actions are driven by subjective desire rather than objective truth. The plot focuses on moral transgression and human fallibility without any apparent appeal to faith or a higher moral law, aligning with a morally relativistic worldview, though it does not explicitly attack religion.