← Back to Supergirl
Supergirl Season 5
Season Analysis

Supergirl

Season 5 Analysis

Season Woke Score
7.6
out of 10

Season Overview

Season four showed that truth, justice and the American way are stronger than fear and hate, as Supergirl stopped Lex Luthor’s anti-alien campaign with the power of the press, no cape required. As the world returns to normal, some things will never be the same now that Lena knows Kara's secret and the Monitor has arrived on Earth 38!

Season Review

Season five of Supergirl continues the show's focus on intersectional themes, using a superhero narrative to deliver overt social and political commentary. The central plot revolves around the fracturing friendship between Kara Danvers and Lena Luthor, with Lena's 'Non Nocere' project attempting to eradicate humanity's capacity for evil through technology, which serves as a moral engineering allegory. The season also tackles the rise of virtual reality and deepfake technology as tools of societal manipulation by the ancient alien cabal, Leviathan, and a newly ascendant Lex Luthor. Powerful female characters dominate the narrative in heroic and villainous roles, while male characters are largely depicted as incompetent, evil, or sidekicks. Prominent queer relationships and characters are integrated as a normal part of the ensemble, including a storyline addressing anti-trans violence. The overarching message critiques systemic failures and corruption within American institutions, contrasting them with the moral purity of the alien heroes and their allies.

Categorical Breakdown

Identity Politics8/10

The narrative places a major focus on systemic corruption in the United States, as exemplified by a plotline addressing the prison-industrial complex and unfairly long sentences in a small town. The main cast prominently features Black, Martian, and Latinx characters in powerful and heroic roles, including James Olsen who leaves National City to run a hometown newspaper focused on local justice, and Kelly Olsen who battles institutional injustice. The first openly transgender superhero remains a main character, with a dedicated episode focusing on violence against the trans community. The powerful white male, Lex Luthor, is re-established as the primary villain, a symbol of unchecked elite power and deception.

Oikophobia7/10

The season's main plot involves exposing a large-scale alien conspiracy, Leviathan, which manipulates Western civilization through a powerful tech company, Obsidian North, and its pervasive virtual reality system. The critique extends to institutions of journalism, government, and the justice system, framing them as corrupted and failing the people. The heroes' efforts are centered on correcting these deep-seated failures within their own society, rather than celebrating its foundational strength.

Feminism9/10

Female characters consistently hold the highest positions of power and moral authority, including Supergirl, the DEO director, and a genius tech CEO who attempts a utopian global mind-control project. Lena Luthor’s core conflict is driven by her ambition to fix the world through her own genius, completely independent of male intervention. Most male characters are relegated to sidekick roles (Brainiac-5) or are outright antagonists and corrupt figures (Lex Luthor, the corrupt former President). The central relationships are those between women, reinforcing the theme of female superiority and self-sufficiency over traditional male/female complementarity or focus on family structures.

LGBTQ+9/10

Queer identities are centered as a normal and significant part of the core team. Alex Danvers, a lead protagonist, is in a stable, committed lesbian relationship with Kelly Olsen. Nia Nal, television's first transgender superhero, remains a main character whose trans identity is explicitly addressed in an episode dealing with anti-trans violence. The show uses these relationships and characters as an overt platform to advocate for sexual and gender ideology.

Anti-Theism5/10

The main ethical conflict centers around Lena Luthor’s 'Non Nocere' project, a technological solution designed to eliminate humanity’s ability to harm, effectively supplanting free will and moral choice with a technical fix. This framework removes the need for transcendent moral law or traditional ethical systems, positioning advanced secular technology and human genius as the source of salvation and moral order. There is a spiritual vacuum where existential issues are treated as engineering problems.