← Back to This Is Us
This Is Us Season 4
Season Analysis

This Is Us

Season 4 Analysis

Season Woke Score
6
out of 10

Season Overview

No specific overview for this season.

Season Review

Season 4 of "This Is Us" marks a transition from a universal story about family loss to a more specialized exploration of intersectional grievances. The central narrative revolves around Randall’s growing realization that his loving, white adoptive family could not provide him with the cultural identity he feels he lacks. This journey into identity politics is punctuated by his insistence on finding a Black therapist, framing shared racial identity as more important than professional merit or existing family bonds. Meanwhile, the show introduces new subplots that emphasize diverse backgrounds over character depth, often feeling like a sociological survey. Female characters are consistently portrayed as the grounding forces of the series, while the men are characterized by fragility and emotional instability. Though the production remains high-quality, the shift toward lecturing the audience on privilege and lived experience is unmistakable.

Categorical Breakdown

Identity Politics8/10

The show centers Randall’s identity as a Black man raised by white parents, treating his childhood as a source of unresolved trauma. It emphasizes racial differences and promotes the idea that individuals require race-specific spaces and professionals for healing.

Oikophobia3/10

The series subtly critiques the traditional white suburban family structure as culturally limiting. It suggests that the Pearsons' colorblind approach to parenting was a form of neglect toward their son's heritage.

Feminism7/10

Women are consistently depicted as the rational and stable members of the household. The male leads are often shown as emotionally broken, unreliable, or needing women to manage their mental health crises.

LGBTQ+7/10

A primary subplot involves a young girl’s discovery of her queer identity. The show frames this coming-out process as a vital act of self-actualization and highlights the need for specialized validation of her choices.

Anti-Theism5/10

The series operates in a post-religious world where the big questions are answered in the therapist's office. Faith is entirely absent, with morality treated as a subjective emotional journey rather than a commitment to objective truth.