← Back to This Is Us
This Is Us Season 5
Season Analysis

This Is Us

Season 5 Analysis

Season Woke Score
8.5
out of 10

Season Overview

No specific overview for this season.

Season Review

Season 5 abandons the show's original focus on universal family bonds to embrace a hyper-fixation on race and identity. The narrative is heavily shaped by the events of 2020, with multiple episodes dedicated to lecturing the audience on systemic racism and white privilege. Randall’s storyline shifts entirely toward his resentment of being raised by a white family, framing his upbringing as a source of trauma rather than a gift. Characters spend more time discussing microaggressions than actual family dynamics. The season also centers a subplot regarding gender identity and pronouns that treats parental hesitation as a moral failure. While the production quality remains high, the storytelling is frequently sidelined by a political agenda that feels forced and preachy.

Categorical Breakdown

Identity Politics10/10

The plot centers Randall's Black identity to the exclusion of all else. He joins a support group for transracial adoptees where the narrative frames white parents as inherently incapable of raising Black children. The show explicitly lectures on systemic oppression and demands the white characters acknowledge their complicity in racial structures.

Oikophobia8/10

The Pearson family history is rewritten to frame their 'colorblind' love as a form of racial negligence. The narrative treats the traditional American family unit as a flawed institution that suppressed Randall's 'true' self. Ancestral traditions are scrutinized through the lens of modern racial grievances.

Feminism6/10

Madison chooses to call off her wedding at the last minute to focus on self-actualization, prioritizing personal independence over the nuclear family. Beth is depicted as the emotional anchor of her household, while Randall is often portrayed as emotionally unstable and dependent on her strength.

LGBTQ+8/10

The season focuses on Tess's transition into a non-binary/queer identity. The narrative frames her mother’s difficulty with new pronouns as a character flaw. The show centers 'correct' terminology and ideological compliance as the primary measure of a parent's love.

Anti-Theism4/10

Traditional religion is largely absent, replaced by a secular, moral-relativist 'cosmic' spirituality. While not openly hostile to Christianity, the show treats moral truth as something found within the self rather than through transcendent or religious frameworks.